So many of these words found in conversations, speeches, books, and memories are related to education, but not directly to academics. While I find the content and skills taught through the various disciplines to be vitally important, I also recognize that much of the learning that takes place in middle school is about life.
Some words came from the valedictorian speech of CDS graduate of 2011 Manfred Reiche in which he reminisced about his years at our school. When he described middle school, Manfred mentioned the annual Olympic Festival, the seventh grade Geography Fair, and the eighth grade trip to Manuel Antonio National Park, all events that elicited strong feelings at the time.
We had our most recent Olympic Festival three weeks ago. It was an all day celebration that involved all 12 advisories reinventing themselves as countries with their own governments, economies, colors, t-shirts, national dances, sports, and mascots. The dances and silly games were absolutely wonderful! But what stood out in my mind were the words I overheard spoken by a member of our service organization, Roots and Shoots, on the telephone half an hour before lunch. “Are you sure you don’t have any special deals today, no two for one, or anything like that? Well, what can you give us? We’re ordering a lot of pizza!” Then she grinned, agreed to something, and disconnected. “We’re getting free drinks!” she announced. This 13 year-old was honing negotiation skills through a pizza sale to raise money for charity.
Other words came from the elective I teach on study skills. Last week I asked the students if they liked school. All of them did for the same reason, “It’s where we get to see our friends.” What they didn’t like? Homework, tests, and quizzes. One acknowledged, “Homework is good for you, but when there is too much you get tired a lot.” According to their words, middle school isn’t about academics; it’s about friends.
I am an admirer of John W. Gardner, the Harvard professor who developed the theory of multiple intelligences. My favorite words from Dr. Gardner are, “Much education today is monumentally ineffective. All too often we are giving young people cut flowers when we should be teaching them to grow their own plants.”
Four years ago I went through a period of uncertainty about the way I taught language arts. I thought that my structured approach emphasizing grammar, vocabulary, reading, and research was solid, but if students didn’t remember half of what I taught them, why was I teaching it? I think I was giving my students too many cut flowers. When I shifted to critical thinking and put student interests and concerns at the center of the curriculum while forcing them to be critical of their own thinking, students became more engaged. Growing their own plants seemed to be the answer.
I’ve also been talking with students about the purpose of education. That’s pretty advanced for 12 year-olds, but a class of seventh graders gave me a lot of words.
• It’s to get us ready for the real things like working and living without your parents and getting food every day.
• It’s so we can get to be intelligent and know a lot of things so when we get out of school we can do well in life and not be on the streets; we’ll have a house.
• It’s to open the doors and give us the opportunities to get into the best university.
• Prepare you for life, get organized, be intelligent.
• The education you get will help you know what to do when a bad situation comes.
• To know what is right and what is wrong.
Notice that not one child said that the purpose of education was to learn English or math or science? Some were thinking about education leading to more education which tells me they don’t really know the purpose of education. Others mentioned learning to manage life. These kids know they will have to grow their own plants.
Philosopher and educator John Dewey has also given me words. He believed that the only real purpose of education is growth. The child learns and grows by doing and interacting with his or her social and cultural environment. Our different experiences help shape our humanness and determine our values. Forcing children to focus exclusively on ideas and values foreign to their own experiences results in disengaged, unthinking people. Education must allow children to learn to solve problems within their own contexts. In his words, “We only think when we are confronted with problems.”
Here are some words from science teacher Scott DeBoer. “I got into education because I wanted the opportunity to influence kids, to set them up with the tools to be successful in life. It can mean academic tools, but also social tools. A big part of my role is not necessarily to teach everything but to facilitate the learning, then extend learning through a trial and error process. I give tools, a basic understanding, but then how to implement a project; they have to figure that out.”
Have you read the book by Robert Fulghum, All I Really Need To Know I Learned in Kindergarten? Among the things Mr. Fulghum learned in kindergarten were the following:
• Play fair.
• Don’t take things that aren’t yours.
• Say you’re sorry when you hurt somebody.
• Wash your hands before you eat.
• Flush.
• When you go out into the world, watch out for traffic, hold hands, and stick together.
• Goldfish and hamsters and white mice and even the little seed in the Styrofoam cup – they all die. So do we.
A couple of weeks ago I got some words from our middle school counselor, Isabel Urrutia, who came to me with a quote that she wanted to use in her eighth grade life skills class. She is in the habit of beginning classes with a brief discussion from Sean Covey’s book Daily Reflections for Highly Effective Teens. She wanted to know what I thought of these words, “Don’t let school get in the way of your education. Although grades are important, becoming truly educated is more important, so make sure you don’t forget why you’re going to school.” We talked about it and I mentioned that a thoughtful discussion on a provocative idea like this could be a very meaningful experience for her students. Afterwards, Isabel shared with me that students were at first confused by the quote, but as they began analyzing it, they came to realize that learning comes in many forms and much of it is not really academic, but skills for life.
I have more words related to my own childhood education. In my classes, the teacher was the authority and, along with text books, the source of information. Students were expected to master the information as given. The purpose of education was obvious. You went to school to learn the 3 R’s of Reading, wRiting, and aRithmetic so you could grow up to be a productive, democratic citizen with a job.
Today, traditional classrooms still prevail, but many teachers who currently teach in our CDS middle school have modernized their teaching methods. Students learn to create, manipulate, and use information to solve real-life problems, often reaching beyond the classroom to use global resources. Both teachers and students are expected to think creatively and critically. I know that I can count on our middle school teachers to get across the important academic content and skills that students need to be successful in middle school, high school, and eventually college and work. You only have to see our standardized test scores each year to know they are doing a fine job. Our average middle school student is at least two years above grade level in basic language and math skills, as well as in science and social studies. But I also feel confident that teachers have not neglected areas such as communication, collaboration, problem-solving, and critical thinking. We have reached a point in which academics and life skills are balanced. And that is what middle school is all about.
Clearly, I agree with John Dewy when he said, “Education is a social process; education is growth; education is not a preparation for life but is life itself.” If you have any words on that, I’d love to hear from you.
